If the Pope could gravely err, any dogma could be wrong

1 Argument

0 Citations

1 Consequence

1 Mention

Arguments

Argument #45dd8300 0 0 1

If it is true that...

If the Pope could gravely err, he could err about doctrine of infallibility 0 0 1

and

If the doctrine of infallibility is wrong, any dogma could be wrong 0 0 1

Then it must be true that...

If the Pope could gravely err, any dogma could be wrong 0 0 1

Opposing Arguments

No opposing arguments found

Citations

No citations found

Consequences

Argument #4b66e426 0 0 1

If it is true that...

Catholic dogma cannot be wrong 0 0 1

and

If the Pope could gravely err, any dogma could be wrong 0 0 1

Then it must be true that...

The Pope cannot gravely err 0 0 1

Mentions

The Modern Boethius/The Pope cannot gravely err

Maintained by

alexandershortt

0•

Updated

Related Propositions

The Pope holds supreme authority over the entire Christian Church 1 0 2 According to Christ's ordinance, Peter is to have successors in his primacy over the whole Church and for all time 1 0 2 The successors of Peter in the Primacy are the bishops of Rome 1 0 2 The Pope is infallible when he speaks ex cathedra 1 0 2 In the final decision on doctrines concerning faith and morals, the Church is infallible 1 0 2 The primary object of Infallibility is the formally revealed truths of Christian Doctrine concerning faith and morals 1 0 2 The Pope cannot gravely err 0 0 1 If the Pope could gravely err, he could err about doctrine of infallibility 0 0 1 Catholic dogma cannot be wrong 0 0 1 If the doctrine of infallibility is wrong, any dogma could be wrong 0 0 1