Retinopathy of prematurity has not blinded tens of thousands of people

Negation: Retinopathy of prematurity has blinded tens of thousands of people 1 0 2

0 Arguments

0 Citations

0 Consequences

0 Mentions

Arguments

No arguments found

Opposing Arguments

Argument #276c85e6 1 0 2

If it is true that...

Premature babies are often given extra oxygen, which tends to cause vasoconstriction by displacing carbon dioxide 1 0 2

and

Supplemental oxygen without carbon dioxide causes vasoconstriction, reducing the tissues' supply of glucose as well as oxygen and damages the retina when combined with too much light 1 0 2

Then it must be true that...

Retinopathy of prematurity has blinded tens of thousands of people 1 0 2

Argument #41143869 1 0 2

If it is true that...

Synthetic glucocorticoids are often given to premature babies, adding to the risk of retinal damage 1 0 2

and

The use of synthetic glucocorticoid hormone is standard in treating very premature babies although it is known to contribute to eye damage 1 0 2

Then it must be true that...

Retinopathy of prematurity has blinded tens of thousands of people 1 0 2

Argument #64d6ea88 1 0 2

If it is true that...

Supplemental oxygen without carbon dioxide causes vasoconstriction, reducing the tissues' supply of glucose as well as oxygen and damages the retina when combined with too much light 1 0 2

and

Bright light contributes to retinal damage in babies 1 0 2

Then it must be true that...

Retinopathy of prematurity has blinded tens of thousands of people 1 0 2

Argument #75e1db53 1 0 2

If it is true that...

Retinal injury is caused by ordinary light when the eyes are sensitized by melatonin, prolactin, and polyunsaturated fats 1 0 2

and

Melatonin and prolactin are induced by stress 1 0 2

and

Darkness is a stress because it impairs mitochondrial energy production 1 0 2

and

Polyunsaturated fats that accumulate in the brain and retina damage mitochondria 1 0 2

Then it must be true that...

Retinopathy of prematurity has blinded tens of thousands of people 1 0 2

Argument #a31941da 1 0 2

If it is true that...

The fetus accumulates a very large amount of iron and absorbs melatonin from the maternal circulation 1 0 2

and

Prolactin is sometimes elevated in the newborn 1 0 2

and

Premature babies are often given extra oxygen, which tends to cause vasoconstriction by displacing carbon dioxide 1 0 2

and

Synthetic glucocorticoids are often given to premature babies, adding to the risk of retinal damage 1 0 2

Then it must be true that...

Retinopathy of prematurity has blinded tens of thousands of people 1 0 2

Argument #bd322d38 1 0 2

If it is true that...

Light and stress, especially with excess iron, damage the retina when the cells contain too much PUFA 1 0 2

Then it must be true that...

Retinopathy of prematurity has blinded tens of thousands of people 1 0 2

Argument #da2afd6f 1 0 2

If it is true that...

The use of synthetic glucocorticoid hormone is standard in treating very premature babies although it is known to contribute to eye damage 1 0 2

and

Cortisol-like drugs damage the brain and other organs 1 0 2

Then it must be true that...

Retinopathy of prematurity has blinded tens of thousands of people 1 0 2

Argument #e3adc57f 1 0 2

If it is true that...

Iron supplements and supplemental oxygen can do the most damage when used with a vitamin E deficiency exacerbated by excessive unsaturated fats in the diet 1 0 2

Then it must be true that...

Retinopathy of prematurity has blinded tens of thousands of people 1 0 2

Citations

No citations found

Consequences

No arguments found

Mentions

No mentions found

Related Propositions

Retinopathy of prematurity has blinded tens of thousands of people 1 0 2 Degeneration of the retina is the main cause of blindness in old people 1 0 2 Retinal injury is caused by ordinary light when the eyes are sensitized by melatonin, prolactin, and polyunsaturated fats 1 0 2 Bright light isn't harmful to the retina if the retina isn't sensitized 1 0 2 The retina becomes easier to injure by light in old age for some of the same reasons that the infant's retina is susceptible 1 0 2 Synthetic glucocorticoids are often given to premature babies, adding to the risk of retinal damage 1 0 2 Bright light contributes to retinal damage in babies 1 0 2 Creating a "deficiency" of DHA prevents retinal damage from light 1 0 2 The use of synthetic glucocorticoid hormone is standard in treating very premature babies although it is known to contribute to eye damage 1 0 2 Copper and magnesium deficiencies predispose to retinal damage 1 0 1